Quantcast
 

Vibration Workouts: Some Benefit Claims on Shaky Ground

Thu, 05/31/2007 - 9:15am by FitSugar
5,493 Views - 8 comments

I have never tried a Power Plate, but something about it just reminds me of those vibrating belt machines from the 1950s. You know, where you put the vibrating belt around your bum and it was supposed to jiggle all the fat off.

Basically, there are two major players in vibrational exercise these days, one being the Power Plate, which is a small standing platform that vibrates really fast with a handle (it kind of looks like a floor polisher or a vacuum cleaner on steroids). The other Whole Body Vibration, made by Soloflex, is an over sized vibrating skateboard with no handles. You can pretty much do any move on these machines, from squats to yoga poses, from push-ups to standing hammer curls. The workout is closer to weightlifting than aerobics, like strength, core and balance training all rolled into one.

The list of claimed benefits from this type of workout is rather long: improves flexibility and strength, reduces pain and stress, builds muscle and reverses osteoporosis, but the most praised benefit by far is the decrease in workout time. Getting all shook up while doing alternating lunges really taxes your muscles. NASA is even investigating vibrational strength training as a means of reducing muscle atrophy and bone loss that accompany long trips in space.

Interested in the downside of this kind of workout? Then read more

However, some researchers are not completely sold on these vibration workouts. The major concern being that high-amplitude vibration can be dangerous over time since it sends jarring waves throughout the body. This jarring motion could create low back pain, cartilage damage, blurred vision from retinal tears, hearing loss and even brain damage (gray matter being shaken too hard in the skull). Soloflex even recommends using the device only 30 minutes a day. More than that and you exceed industry standards for safe vibrations in the workplace. I never thought I would hear OSHA rules applied to fitness machines.

Keeping all this in mind, I still want to try a vibrational work out, do you? Let me know in the comments below.


Related Fit Stories

Related Network Stories


 
 
 

8 Comments Add a Comment

  • LilPeaPod's picture
    LilPeaPod
    2

    I saw one of these demonstrated at Brookstone. The guy who was testing it couldn't bend over and touch his toes before getting on and then after was able to pass his toes and touch the floor.
    My bf thinks it was the placebo effect. I am not really convinced either.

    1 year 31 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Butrfly4404's picture
    Butrfly4404
    3

    Dude...my grandma actually has one of those belt things...STILL. I was so tempted to turn it on last weekend!

    1 year 31 weeks ago Report Comment
  • leeluvfashion's picture
    leeluvfashion
    4

    I would still try it although I don't know if I would like it. However, it does spark some interest.

    1 year 31 weeks ago Report Comment
  • KrisSugar's picture
    KrisSugar
    5

    my granparents had a fat shaking machine in their garage. that was so fun! i guess no one ever thought of actually doing an exercise on it.

    1 year 31 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Jivespeaker's picture
    Jivespeaker
    7

    I'd read a while back that Madonna uses this in her workout... must be nice!

    1 year 31 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Kaellya's picture
    Kaellya
    8

    I tried one just yesterday. Slightly weird - you definitely have to keep your knees soft or all the vibrations go to your head. It definitely has a more weight-lifting type effect - I wasn't breathless at all afterwards, but my muscles felt worked out (though not at all sore).
    A nice addition to a routine, but it would be a bit boring to do everyday. It's not as satisfying as running or lifting x kilograms of weight.

    1 year 31 weeks ago Report Comment

Leave a Comment

To post comments, please log in or register.



Morsels of goodness, delivered daily.

Enter your email below:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 











©1976-2009 Sugar Inc. | Privacy (updated July-4-2008) | Terms of Use | Copyright Policy | Advertise | Contact Us